Eighteen Months to the Right Home in Leonia

Eighteen Months to the Right Home in Leonia

The Selleck Group | KW City Views Realty

Scott Selleck · Broker / Sales Associate · Request an appointment at meet.sellecksellsnj.com

Serving Bergen and Hudson County · SRES®, e-PRO® · Licensed since 1993. Over 500 transactions closed.

Eighteen Months to the Right Home in Leonia

On November 16, 2026, at 3:00 PM, my buyers closed on 126 Sylvan Avenue in Leonia at $820,000. I represented the buyers. Their search took a year and a half, and an hour after we left the closing table, they posted a review I want to share, with their permission, because it says something about buying a home that numbers never will.

Listen to this article (AI-narrated audio, 5:50)

How long does it take to find the right home in Leonia?

Short answer: It can take longer than buyers expect, and a long search is not a failed one. Leonia is a small town, so the right house for your needs may not come up every month. My buyers at 126 Sylvan Avenue searched for a year and a half. They knew what they wanted, kept their financing ready, and recognized the right house when it appeared.

Updated November 17, 2026. Source: my buyer-side closing at 126 Sylvan Avenue, Leonia, November 16, 2026.

Scott Selleck with his buyers at the closing for 126 Sylvan Avenue in Leonia, New Jersey, keys in hand

Closing day for 126 Sylvan Avenue, Leonia. Shared with the buyers' permission. Closing document blurred for privacy.

This one is personal for me. I grew up in Leonia, and helping buyers make a home here is a different feeling than any other closing.

In their words

"At every step of the process, we had so much to learn, and honestly, we often had no idea what we were supposed to do next. But Scott was always there for us. He patiently explained every detail, guided us through each step, and made sure we never felt lost or alone." Hansaem Lee, Google review, November 16, 2026

I read that line about never feeling lost more than once. That is the part of this work that does not show up on a closing statement, and it is the part buyers remember.

Keys at the closing table

I take a lot of pride in every closing I have with clients buying in Leonia. I take even more pride in doing everything I can so they leave the closing with a set of keys.

On closing day, that almost did not happen. A last-minute issue came up at the final walkthrough, so I went back to the house, confirmed it was resolved, and brought the keys to the closing myself, with a bottle of champagne. Getting the keys is a very special moment, and I did not want them to miss it.

A long search is not a failed search

Eighteen months can feel like something went wrong. Usually it means the opposite. These buyers had a clear idea of what they wanted and what mattered to them. They did not want to settle, and they were willing to be patient. Just as important, they kept a positive attitude through the whole process, and that made everything more workable and got us to the finish line.

In a small town like Leonia, the right house for your needs may not come up every month. Every house you pass on, and every one you lose, teaches you something about what you actually want. By the time the right one appears, you recognize it, and you are ready to move.

Why this house was the one

126 Sylvan Avenue was presented really well. It sits in a very good location in town, between Broad Avenue and Grand Avenue. It has a lot of windows and great natural light, and it has the cozy feeling of a house that has been well maintained. When you have waited eighteen months, you know the right one as soon as you see it.

What I tell buyers who are a year in

Revisit the list, not the goal. After a year of looking, most buyers know which of their original must-haves still matter and which ones were never really theirs. Write the list again from scratch.

Keep your financing current. Pre-approvals are based on a point in time. Update yours with your lender so it is ready the day the right house appears, not the week after.

Know what happens next before it happens. Attorney review, inspection, appraisal, the mortgage commitment and the walkthrough each come with their own questions. My job is to explain each step before you reach it, so you know what is coming before you reach the closing table.

Expect honesty about the house, not only encouragement. As your buyer's agent, I am looking out for your interests. Sometimes that means telling you a house is not the one, even when you are tired of looking.

Questions buyers ask me about a long search

What happened at the final walkthrough?
A last-minute issue came up at the final walkthrough, so I went back to the house, confirmed it was resolved, and brought the keys to the closing myself.

Why did the search take eighteen months?
My buyers knew what they wanted, did not want to settle, and kept a positive attitude the whole way.

What made 126 Sylvan Avenue the right house?
A very good location between Broad Avenue and Grand Avenue, a lot of windows and natural light, and the cozy feel of a well-maintained home.

Who this is for

Buyers in Leonia and across Bergen County who have been searching for a year or longer and are starting to wonder whether they should keep going.

Meet with Me

I would be glad to talk it through with you, whether you are working with an agent yet or not. Request an appointment, or call me on my cell at (201) 970-3960.

If you have a home to sell before you buy, take my Selleck Client Resource Hub quiz. It takes 7 questions and about 90 seconds. You can also read more client reviews.

Have a quick question first? Ask my AI assistant on Delphi. It is an AI trained on my material, not a person.

Scott Selleck
Broker / Sales Associate | The Selleck Group | KW City Views Realty
SRES® (Seniors Real Estate Specialist®) | e-PRO® | Licensed since 1993. Over 500 transactions closed.
2200 Fletcher Avenue, Suite 502, Fort Lee, NJ 07024
Cell: (201) 970-3960 | Office: (201) 592-8900
Email: [email protected]
Website: SelleckSellsNJ.com
Request an appointment: meet.sellecksellsnj.com
AI assistant: https://www.delphi.co/scottselleck
NJ Real Estate Broker / Sales Associate License #9236275

Licensure does not imply endorsement. FL Real Estate Sales Associate License #SL3588731, Keller Williams Boca Raton Realty. Keller Williams City Views Realty and Keller Williams Boca Raton Realty. Each office is independently owned and operated. Broker compensation in New Jersey is fully negotiable and is not set by law or by any board or association of REALTORS®. This article is general information only and is not legal, tax, or financial advice. Confirm details for your own purchase with your real estate attorney or lender. Review shared with the buyers' written permission. Equal Housing Opportunity.

NJ License #9236275 KW City Views Realty | FL License #SL3588731 Keller Williams Boca Raton Realty | Equal Housing Opportunity
#ScottSelleckRealtor #BergenCountyRealtor #NorthernNJRealtor #KWCityViews

Work With Scott

Scott Selleck has been licensed since 1993 and has closed over 500 transactions across Northern New Jersey. NJ REALTORS Circle of Excellence Sales Award: Platinum 2021 and 2022, Gold 2015, 2017, 2019, 2024 and 2025, Silver 2018. Put his local knowledge and transaction experience to work for you.